When adding to a category move the "and more" sign down below the new character please! -Felicity
- Johnny Ghost; A spunky ghost hunter that's part of PIE.
- Papa Acachalla; A chubby, yet lovable, Acachalla family father.
- Officer Maloney; A Murder (Gamemode) character. "The best sharpshooter in the west" and a sheriff.
- Jimmy Casket; A familiar serial killer in the Murder (Gamemode) Series.
- Asylum Kyte Weaver; The protagonist of the Oblivion Tale series.
- Vahl Aradur; The protagonist of the Skyrim Tale series.
- Cywren Caster; The protagonist of his Fallout 3/ Fallout New Vegas Tale.
- Stardust Sprinkleshine; A plucky unicorn that arises from The Floating Gun of the Aztecs on occasion.
- Spencer; A nerdy kid that is one of the adopted son's in the acachalla family house load and locked in the basement of the acachalles by the acachalles.
- Jenny Ghost; Another version of Johnny Ghost that was created with Jenny Toast.
- Lights Zeron; 'best' FNAF guard ever. With the "I Need My Knife Back" song as his theme song which he constantly sings.
- Ben Swolo; the shirtless Ben Swolo, who is from the line of the knights of swol. His father (Han Swolo) was killed by Ben.
- Darth Calculus; An evil person from the star wars videos
- Cywren Caster; the smartest Waste-lander and main character in A Fallout Tale.
- And more
- Johnny Toast; A British ghost hunter working in the main PIE unit.
- Sally Acachalla; The Acachalla family's waffle-loving girl.
- Thumbalerena; Much like Stardust, arising from The Floating Gun of the Aztecs.
- Teenage Jeff the Killer; During the Creepy Pasta High School episode.
- Jenny Toast; Another version of Johnny Toast that was created at the same time as the other Ghost, her partner.
- And More.
- Gertrude; The Acachalla household Gingerian. Papa Acachalla's wife and the adopted mother of Sally and Billy.
- Aimée; A French ghost girl who has spunk and a crush on some specific PIE members.
- Fred Spooker; An annoying and lovable Paranormal Investigators Extraordinaire member.
- Maddie Friend; A Billy loving crazy girl with a pen and a shirt.
- Slender Man; During the Creepy Pasta High School episode.
- Cardboard Friend; The box enitity that haunted a young Gregory.
- And More!
- Billy Acachalla; The medic and reviving member of the Acachalla family.
- Chris "Colon" Ghostie; Another PIE member/intern like Fred Spooker.
- Sue Acachalla; The unknown gender'd child of the Acachalla's.
- Maxwell Acachalla; A southern, Acachalla gang member, man and the brother of Papa Acachalla.
- Prince Fang; A paranormal dragon that travels from the 13th dimension.
- Toilet Toucher; A old man that travels between toilets when touching them with his skin(butt).
- and more!