Johnny Roast was a member of the original Paranormal Investigators Extraordinaire (alongside Ronnie Boast and the series regulars, Johnny Ghost and Johnny Toast). He has not been seen in a video since 2014.
- The same name was used by BethanyFrye as Johnny Toast, as she couldn't remember the exact "oast" word used. And in one of the Prop Hunt videos, Johnny Ghost's name was mistaken for Roast's name.
- Johnny Roast is the Toilet Toucher's favorite member of the Paranormal Investigators Extraordinaire.
- Interestingly, Bethany would later play Isaac's Johnny Boast, now renamed "Ronnie".
- His appearance as a ghost during Prop Hunt doesn't count, as Ghost and Toast are also seen as ghosts in the rounds.