Board Thread:Special Projects Division/@comment-25867149-20170323101408/@comment-28885584-20171129163201

You say that, but Canada celebrates that, Norfolk Island does, Liberia does, Netherlands do, Philippines do, The Saint Lucia Nation does.

And that is for thanksgiving, not for similar holidays.

Similar holidays

Germany's Erntedankfest Japan's Labor Thanksgiving Day The UK's harvest festival India and a couple other places have Thai Pongal

Now, I could spend another 30 minutes on that topic, but I'm not done yet.

Realistically, The colonists were the ones making the feast, eating the feast, and celebrating with gun fire, and probably fireworks(if they had existed).

The native Americans just showed up to see why they were shooting guns and blowing stuff up.

Hold on, I have one more point.

The historic date of the celebration is different then the day we celebrate, because the celebration wasn't really a big thing. It was up to the states and individuals to celebrate until Lincoln made it a federal holiday and stuff in the 1860's.

Final thing:

They weren't undocumented. Ships have manuscripts, remember?